daxterdd:

So I know some folks have interpreted it differently, but I actually really appreciate that Blaine specifies “I transfered schools to be with you” instead of just a cop out like “I transferred for you.”

Because to Blaine, it’s totally worth changing his life and changing schools and leaving the glory he got as Warbler’s frontman just so that he could be with Kurt more.

I don’t think Blaine resents changing his life like that for Kurt, because to him that’s all been worthwhile.  What he does resent is that Kurt feels like it’s not enough, and that instead of enjoying their time together, Kurt is always making plans for the future. Plans to leave Blaine behind once again. And now, plans with someone else.

And this time Blaine doesn’t even have the solace of “after school and on weekends” to comfort him.

Yessss. I’ve been sort of quietly questioning the motives of all the parallel posts of Kurt questioning him at the time vs Blaine bringing it up here because there is a HUGE DIFFERENCE between “for you” and “to be with you.” And maybe Kurt and some viewers are hearing the former, but in my mind Blaine definitely means exactly what he said.

Also, the idea that Blaine’s frustrated and panicking because this argument pings a deep and paralyzing fear in him that Blaine as he is now isn’t good enough for Kurt, that he can’t grow fast enough to keep up with Kurt, that Kurt will move somewhere beyond Blaine’s reach, that perhaps Kurt is actively TRYING to move beyond his reach? Really easily explains for me why Blaine would choose this line of defense after Kurt accuses Blaine of not affirming him enough. In Blaine’s eyes, his entire LIFE as it is now is an affirmation of how special Kurt is.* Kurt MOVES him, and it’s terrifying to Blaine that Kurt might regard that essential fact of their relationship as a thing of their past, and not of their present or future. 

And it really easily explains why I Have Nothing failed to resolve this argument and Blaine’s hurt. I mean, setting aside the fact that Kurt essentially took a leaf out of the Finchel relationship handbook, how would you feel if the person you love and idolize and have already changed everything for told you via heart-rending ballad that they’re going to continue moving forward full speed ahead, with or without you, but if it’s without you it will hurt them deeply, so keep up damn it? Blaine is already trying his hardest to keep up. Kurt’s the one who did something morally ambiguous here. I Have Nothing honestly only adds insult to injury. It’s certainly not an apology, and it’s extremely manipulative (remember, Kurt knows that he moves Blaine). Moreover, it puts the onus on Blaine to surrender in this conflict by heavily implying Blaine’s in danger of failing at what he’s put his whole heart and soul into (e.g. making Kurt happy, becoming the kind of person who can stay with Kurt for the long haul). It’s less a concession and more a blatant escalation. 

Of course, Kurt doesn’t understand this. He doesn’t even know this is the core issue for most of the episode. To him, he’s the one who’s always had to chase after Blaine. He’s the one who’s had to constantly deal with Blaine’s considerable and much more mainstream (professional and personal) appeal. He’s the one who has been neglected in the face of Blaine’s anxiety over his dependence on Kurt. And all of that is fair. TL;DR: All this means is just that teenage egos are needy as fuck, and that these two need to remember to communicate because their insecurities clash too easily against each other if they don’t.

*And thus, the metatext becomes the actual text. Lol, Glee. You make my brain hurt.

lettersfromtitan:

The notable difference is that Kurt finds strength and victory in his rage (or after it) as a rule.  Blaine does not.

That’s a really good thought. And this isn’t quite related but

I think it’s interesting that Kurt’s rage song is a fantasy that gets staged—he ends up performing it and is acknowledged to have done so by the literal narrative i.e. Burt—whereas Blaine’s rage song is a staged fantasy—the staged part more than likely happens entirely inside Blaine’s head.

I mean, the only parts of Fighter that are acknowledged as really happening are the walking away and the boxing/shower scene. And even those “real” parts are mostly a headspace performance where, while the action is probably literal, the singing is probably not. So the staged part at the end, with Blaine wearing the same clothes but having acquired a technically elaborate set, reads to me as almost certainly being a fantasy. And since no one was there to see the performance if it was real, it’s no more potent than a fantasy anyway.

So by considering these two performances together, we get this indication that Kurt automatically projects his pain out—his feelings immediately inform a song choice and quickly become a performance—while Blaine’s feelings, even within himself, are experienced in real time through imagined song and performance, on a stage he keeps locked inside himself along with his pain. So we see Kurt have this moment of struggle and wrath that leads to resolution, and we see an achingly similar moment with Blaine that fails to resolve anything.

Which makes the fact that Kurt encourages him to actually sing for/with Cooper and have that duet moment really lovely, because obviously they’re working with similar headspaces. Kurt sees that Blaine’s still struggling with it, so he encourages Blaine to harness that performative tendency and embody it, to use it constructively as a force for communication and change like Kurt has had success with in the past. And obviously that works out much better.

TL;DR: listen to your boyfriend, Blaine. Good things happen when you do.

mzminola:

“Hey guys. My name is Mercedes Jones. So most of you know, Cheerios is about perfection, and winning. Looking hot, and being popular. Well I think that it should be about something different. How many of you at this school feel fat?”

[Quinn raises her hand, girl in green looks at Quinn, and then raises her own hand]

“How many of you feel like you’re not worth very much? That you’re ugly, or that you have too many dimples and not enough friends?”

[hey Jesse. What’s up with you?]

“Well I felt all those things about myself at one time or another. Heck I felt most of those things about myself today. And that just ain’t right. And we’ve got something to say about it. And if you like what we have to say, come down here and sing it with us.”

…this is her forming a choir out of the girl!Cheerios, and other students at the school. THIS IS CHOIR SUMMONING POWERS.

I really like this headcanon. She’s the pied piper of chorus members! A power perfected over years of having her church’s choir wrapped around her little finger? They do seem more than happy to show up for any song Mercedes is involved with that needs a gospel moment.

pippipklooray:

linkindenka:

when Finn told them that he don’t have anything special in his life, he immediately looked up to Rachel….

Yes, omg. Finn sitting there, complaining about how empty his life was while his girlfriend was RIGHT THERE drove me insane. Like, I sympathized with Finn because he had a huge bomb dropped on him and that wasn’t cool. And obviously I don’t think he should be defining his worth through his girlfriend (because look how that turned out). But I was just like…ouch. I doubt Rachel appreciates this.

I think it’s interesting that as Finn is saying this, Rachel has this weird epiphany moment that leads directly into Without You. We talk about how unhealthy it is that Finn puts all of his self-worth into his relationship with Rachel, but I think the way Rachel encourages it (remember how she comforted Finn with the “gift” of her virginity in TFT? and how she’s about to sing him a song about how her success is dependent upon his love and support?) is just as unhealthy. And so, for me, this glance of Kurt’s is a kind of “what what what are you doing” look, like he can actually hear the strains of the song starting up in the background/in her head. I think Kurt saw their engagement coming from a mile away.

pippipklooray:

linkindenka:

when Finn told them that he don’t have anything special in his life, he immediately looked up to Rachel….

Yes, omg. Finn sitting there, complaining about how empty his life was while his girlfriend was RIGHT THERE drove me insane. Like, I sympathized with Finn because he had a huge bomb dropped on him and that wasn’t cool. And obviously I don’t think he should be defining his worth through his girlfriend (because look how that turned out). But I was just like…ouch. I doubt Rachel appreciates this.

I think it’s interesting that as Finn is saying this, Rachel has this weird epiphany moment that leads directly into Without You. We talk about how unhealthy it is that Finn puts all of his self-worth into his relationship with Rachel, but I think the way Rachel encourages it (remember how she comforted Finn with the “gift” of her virginity in TFT? and how she’s about to sing him a song about how her success is dependent upon his love and support?) is just as unhealthy. And so, for me, this glance of Kurt’s is a kind of “what what what are you doing” look, like he can actually hear the strains of the song starting up in the background/in her head. I think Kurt saw their engagement coming from a mile away.

Glee: Sex, death, the Anubis archetype, and Kurt Hummel

lettersfromtitan:

This is about as not triggery as a discussion that references last night’s episode can be, but it’s still references last night’s episode and Dave, so please proceed with caution.

As usual, I cannot get enough of rm’s meta. This piece kind of takes previous discussions of Kurt-as-magician and goes in a very specific and sex-and-death-oriented direction, which I just find incredibly cool.

It might also be interesting to analyze what I’ve been calling Kurt’s canonization—his increasingly rigid (and rigidly enforced) morality—in the context of this archetype. Anubis was a judge, too. He weighed people’s hearts. This may be a terrible generalization born of childhood Egyptology lessons, but I believe if you passed this test, you were allowed to cross over and live forever in the afterlife, but if you failed, you were devoured and your life ended there. That sounds very much like the make-it-or-break-it world of Glee.

So maybe it’s not so much a canonization of Kurt as it is a deification? Does that make it more or less problematic?

You know what my favorite thing about the outstretched hands moment in Reichenbach is?

epaulettes:

That they’re not actually reaching for each other in context.

The actual context of their hands is that Sherlock is putting his hand out saying don’t come any closer, stay where you are, a halting gesture, and John is putting his up in placation, hands in the air where Sherlock can see them, alright, stay calm, no sudden movements, I promise. That’s the actual context of their hands being up and out.

But the subtext of the scene is so viscerally the opposite, conveyed in the tightness of the shots, the emotional freneticism of the hand-held camera struggling to focus and constantly shifting. The slight lingering in the moment, their fingers outstretched, suspended in the air and framed in such a way that superimposed they would be just barely touching. And worst of all, the fact that the shots are switched in order of cause and effect, John’s hand seen up before Sherlock’s is seen out, confusing the audience for a moment before context settles—for one brief second where, to their eye, Sherlock actually is merely reaching out for that ghost of a touch.

It’s that as every bit of their expressed actions state stay away and I will if you want me to, every bit of the implicit nature of the scene is undermining that and crying out, no, no, I want you with me, don’t go away. My favorite thing is that they’re not actually reaching for each other with their hands, but the show wants us to know that they’re reaching out, somehow, with everything else that they are.

Basically, Sherlock is a brilliantly filmed series, and it should get all the awards.

#i noticed this too actually #it’s sherlock pushing john away and pulling him close and keeping him where he is #it’s john saying he’s right there and trying to get higher and being pushed lower #it’s amazing what just a shot of hands can convey

That’s beautifully put. And as a celebratory coda to this post getting 500 notes, I’d just like to remind everyone that these are the same hands that they held when they were handcuffed to each other earlier. They probably both have bruises on their wrists from where the cuffs chafed and pulled while they ran. Now, hundreds of feet of distance put between them, their hands are still being tied together. The levels of nuance on this fucking show make me crazy.

villainesses
i liked this ep of glee too! like, the kurt/karofsky stuff made me SUPER uncomfortable and as usual everything to do with finn/rachel skeeves me out (EXCEPT HER DADS THAT WAS GREAT), but it was overall really solid and cute and pushing a good agenda well. :D

Glee is a dark comedy and I think Finchel is barreling headlong into a tragic resolution. The show is playing it off for laughs right now, but all spoilers point to something going horrifically wrong in the next ep, and I think whatever that is, it will obliterate the naivety with which they’ve so blithely conducted this engagement thus far. Whether that means they do or don’t actually get married, I’m not sure, but I don’t think they’re going to get off this runaway train without facing some hard truths and serious consequences.

Regarding Karofsky, I’ve been living with the idea that he’s in need of a proper resolution since Prom Queen, so I’m actually pretty okay with how they did that whole bit in this ep. Karofsky is seriously fucking screwed up, but he’s learned how to approach Kurt from a positive and honest (if still wildly inappropriate) place, and I don’t think it’s entirely wrong-footed of the show to make it Kurt’s decision to forgive Karofsky, and reject him kindly, and encourage him firmly to move on. I think by having this moment with Karofsky, Kurt is as much absolving HIMSELF of his own violation as he is absolving Karofsky of being his violator. It’s also removed all of Karofsky’s power over Kurt (even his passing privilege, since he got outed in the process), and left Kurt in an empirically stronger position, which is more than I can say for other ~moral~ decisions Kurt’s made this season.

I know people are uncomfortable that the show keeps writing Kurt into this role where he constantly has to accept being acted upon by stupid and unkind and dangerous forces, and I’m certainly one of them. The overall canonization of Kurt that I’ve noticed this season really annoys the shit out of me, especially after Michael. But I don’t think this particular moment of forgiveness was irresponsibly done, even if it does play into what is, overall, a part of Kurt’s character arc that I’m uncomfortable with.

I don’t know why I vomited this up, but I guess I’m just really actually okay with Glee after an episode and I’m trying to figure out why exactly that is, when the show is still pretty problematic.

I LOVED THIS BIT SO MUCH.

Blaine tries to give Kurt his mike. He’d give up his mike in a heartbeat to make Kurt happy, to give him a chance to shine.

Kurt says, “oh no, no,” and for a second we think it’s modesty, BUT LO, IT IS NOT. KURT HAS HAD A MIKE ALL ALONG. HE IS PERFECTLY PREPARED TO SING, TOO. But he would never take away Blaine’s mike just to have his own moment. They can both have mikes. They can both have their chances. They don’t have to compromise themselves to be able to share this.

Both Blaine and Kurt have their own voices, and they can support each other 100% without either of them ever needing to be less just so that the other has a chance to be more. Kurt knows they can go on just as they are, and they’ll just shine twice as bright.

AND THEN I REALIZE MY OTP IS SO FLAWLESS I HAVE FEELS ABOUT MICROPHONES AND THEN I HAVE TO LOL.

lettersfromtitan:daxterdd:



now pretend that isn’t slushie. 

Oh, God.

I feel like Kurt is half having that moment.  I feel like Kurt keeps having to have this moment over Blaine — there’s the WSS death scene, then this shit happens, there’s his own backstory with loss, and Blaine’s backstory with violence.  I bet Kurt has a lot of nightmares about Blaine’s untimely demise.  And I bet it’s real bad in the wake of this.

I think part of the point of the staging here is to help along this identification and association. I can only imagine what it would be like for Kurt, experiencing the same feelings of violation and horror in real time and with real consequences that we experienced as part of the audience of this narrative.
To elaborate, we are MEANT to see this as a scene of violence and the coloring was chosen specifically for that reason. And it’s very powerful because the mock fighting mechanism of the show (dance offs) and the artificial bullying element of the show (slushies) came together to create a scene of real horror. We’ve been conditioned by the show to disassociate from its acts of menace (dodgeball? really?), so, in a way, by snapping the tone back to a terribly heightened reality (the color of the slushie combined with the actual harm), we feel a deeper disquiet than if Sebastian had literally pulled a knife. (Because on Glee, that would actually be ridiculous. Context is weird that way.) Because horror is something we feel in our brains, and imagined horror is sometimes much worse, and lingers longer, than real horror. For us and Kurt, the fact that it looks so much like real blood is almost as bad, and in some psychological ways, worse, than if it had been Blaine’s blood after all.

lettersfromtitan:daxterdd:

now pretend that isn’t slushie. 

Oh, God.

I feel like Kurt is half having that moment.  I feel like Kurt keeps having to have this moment over Blaine — there’s the WSS death scene, then this shit happens, there’s his own backstory with loss, and Blaine’s backstory with violence.  I bet Kurt has a lot of nightmares about Blaine’s untimely demise.  And I bet it’s real bad in the wake of this.

I think part of the point of the staging here is to help along this identification and association. I can only imagine what it would be like for Kurt, experiencing the same feelings of violation and horror in real time and with real consequences that we experienced as part of the audience of this narrative.

To elaborate, we are MEANT to see this as a scene of violence and the coloring was chosen specifically for that reason. And it’s very powerful because the mock fighting mechanism of the show (dance offs) and the artificial bullying element of the show (slushies) came together to create a scene of real horror. We’ve been conditioned by the show to disassociate from its acts of menace (dodgeball? really?), so, in a way, by snapping the tone back to a terribly heightened reality (the color of the slushie combined with the actual harm), we feel a deeper disquiet than if Sebastian had literally pulled a knife. (Because on Glee, that would actually be ridiculous. Context is weird that way.) Because horror is something we feel in our brains, and imagined horror is sometimes much worse, and lingers longer, than real horror. For us and Kurt, the fact that it looks so much like real blood is almost as bad, and in some psychological ways, worse, than if it had been Blaine’s blood after all.

Screw my heart you did it! You did it Kurt. Who’s gonna tell Blaine? You gotta let me do it. You beat them all, they threw everything at you, they tried to beat you down but you know what? You are unstoppable Kurt, I am so proud to be your dad. They can never take this away from you. Right now, in this moment, on this day, you won.

Burt Hummel (via colferandthebeast)

Can we talk about the evolution of Burt’s relationship with Blaine?  First there was the awkward sex talk.  And he was probably pretty weirded out when Blaine and Kurt started dating.  Maybe he’s tried real hard to make sure they don’t have opportunities to have sex.  Maybe he’s actually completely chill about it because his son is loved and safe, I don’t know.  But by this scene, it’s like he’s acquired yet another son, and he’s like “mine mine mine to tell the news to.”  That’s so interesting.  How did it happen?

(via lettersfromtitan)

What I found interesting is that Burt seems to be in a position to tell Blaine before Kurt. It seems likely to me that he was visiting Blaine in the hospital, which is very much a “you are part of my family” gesture. Or it’s possible he went specifically so that he could bring updates to Kurt, since it’s news about Blaine that Kurt thinks his dad’s come to talk to him about. That’s still a touchingly intimate role to take up between your teenage son and his boyfriend. It’s lovely and inexplicable and implies so much permanency.